Search engine visitors - click here to access entire "$ensible Home" web site
Return to Main Reference Topics List
To read James Dulley's columns which are related to the various section topics below, click on the three-digit column code link(s) listed after the section heading.
Whether you are increasing the insulation levels in your current home or selecting insulation for a new home, choosing the right insulation material can be challenging. Fibrous loose-fill insulations such as cellulose, fiberglass, and rock wool are options you may wish to consider. This publication will introduce you to these materials—what they are, how they are applied, how they compare with each other, and other considerations regarding their use—so that you can decide whether loose fills are right for your home.
The most obvious difference between loose fills and other types of insulation is their form. They are either produced as—or broken down into—shreds, granules, or nodules. These small particles form fluffy materials that conform to the spaces in which they are installed. Loose fills are most commonly sold in bags and are blown into building cavities using special equipment. All three primary types of loose-fill insulation are considered "environmentally positive" because recycled waste materials are used in their production.
Cellulose loose-fill insulation is made from wastepaper, such as used newsprint and boxes, that is shredded and pulverized into small, fibrous particles. Chemicals are added to provide resistance to fire and insects. Also, less energy is required to produce loose-fill cellulose than to produce other insulations.
Fiberglass loose-fill insulation is spun from molten glass into fibers. The glass is typically melted in high-temperature gas furnaces. Most major manufacturers use 20% to 30% recycled glass content.
Rock wool (or slag wool) loose-fill insulation is similar to fiberglass except that it is spun from blast furnace slag (the scum that forms on the surface of molten metal) and other rock-like materials instead of molten glass. The production of rock wool uses by-products that would otherwise be wasted.
Loose-fill insulations are well suited for places where it is difficult to install other types of insulation, such as irregularly shaped areas, around obstructions (such as plumbing stacks), and in hard-to-reach places. They can be installed in either enclosed cavities such as walls or unenclosed spaces such as attics. Blown-in loose fills are particularly useful for retrofit situations because, except for the holes that are sometimes drilled for installations, they are one of the few materials that can be installed without greatly disturbing existing finishes. Rock wool or slag wool loose-fill insulation is often used for insulating existing walls and ceilings in mobile homes.
In most new construction, however, the more common choices in insulation are batts or rolls because they can be installed without the use of special equipment before walls are finished. Batts are available in standard widths designed to match the cavities created by wall studs.
Loose fills are sometimes used in new construction, though. A mixture of loose-fill insulation and an adhesive can be sprayed into wall cavities before the walls are closed. Such methods may result in fewer gaps in the building's thermal envelope than can occur with batts.
| Recommended Specifications by Insulation Type | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Cellulose | Fiberglass | Rock Wool | |
| R-value/inch | 3.2–3.8 | 2.2–2.7 | 3.0–3.3 |
| Inches (cm) needed for R-38 | 10–12 (25–30) | 14–17 (35–43) | 11.5–13 (29–33) |
| Density in lb/ft3 (kg/m3) | 1.5–2.0 (24–36) | 0.5–1.0 (10–14) | 1.7 (27) |
| Weight at R-38 in lb/ft2 (kg/m2) | 1.25–2.0 (6–10) | 0.5–1.2 (3–6) | 1.6–1.8 (8–9) |
| OK for 1/2" drywall, 24" on center? | No | Yes | No |
| OK for 1/2" drywall, 16" on center? | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| OK for 5/8" drywall, 24" on center? | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Comparative Performance of Loose-Fill Insulations
Insulation materials are compared on the basis of their R-values per unit of thickness, density per unit of volume, and weight per unit of area.
There are several performance characteristics to consider when selecting an insulation material. Among the most important to compare are insulating capacity, weight, convective heat loss, settling and loss of insulating capacity, fire resistance, and moisture resistance.
Insulating Capacity
A material's resistance to heat flow is expressed as its R-value. The higher
the R-value, the better the material insulates, and the lesser the thickness
you will need. (However, in an open, unrestricted attic application, the height
limit of insulation thickness is of no great concern. But if you use your attic
for storage, heavy objects will compress insulation and decrease its benefits.)
Different insulations also have different densities, or weights. There are
weight limits for certain ceiling types (see the chart and the section on
Weight that follows).
Weight limits and other factors at R-38 insulation levels are shown in the chart on this page for the three primary types of loose fills. (R-38 is a commonly recommended ceiling insulation level in many parts of the United States. To determine the recommended insulation levels for your area, call the Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Clearinghouse (EREC) listed in the Source List to request the U.S. Department of Energy's Insulation Fact Sheet.)
Weight
Ceiling drywall can sag under heavy loads, such as those sometimes created by
insulation. One drywall manufacturer recommends loads of no more than 1.3
pounds per square foot (6 kilograms per square meter) for 1/2-inch
(1.3-centimeter) ceiling drywall with framing spaced 24 inches (61 centimeters)
on center. The limit increases to 2.2 pounds per square foot (11 kilograms per
square meter) for framing spaced 16 inches (41 centimeters) on center and for
5/8-inch (1.6-centimeter) drywall.
Loose-fill cellulose and rock wool, being heavier materials, could cause the ceiling to sag if installed at R-38 on 1/2-inch (1.3-centimeter) ceiling drywall with framing spaced 24 inches (61 centimeters) on center (see chart). Therefore, when deciding whether to use these materials for new construction, consider switching to 5/8-inch ceiling drywall or, if possible, changing your ceiling framing widths to 16 inches on center.
Some cellulose and rock wool insulation manufacturers include weight limit information on the bag. Because fiberglass is much less dense, its weight on ceiling dry-wall is not a concern.
Convective Heat Loss
Convection is heat flow caused by air cur-rents. Convective heat loss in
insulation is rare, but it can occur when large temperature differences above
and below insulation create tiny air currents (called "convection
loops") within the insulation. Studies have shown that convective heat
loss can occur with lighter density loose-fill fiberglass at the very low attic
temperatures possible in extremely cold climates. Depending on the attic
temperature, the insulation's measured R-value could decrease by as much as
50%.
To minimize these convection loops and their associated effects, some researchers suggest installing blown-in cellulose or a fiberglass blanket on top of the loose-fill fiberglass. Another solution is to purchase one of the currently available "convection blanket" products that can inhibit this convective heat loss.
Cellulose and rock wool are more resistant to airflow than fiberglass because they are denser. They may also be more effective at reducing air leakage and associated heat loss, because their higher densities cause them to settle and seal more around rafters and in corners.
Sprayed-in-place foam insulations are an alternative to loose fills in some applications. They offer higher R-values at lower thicknesses than loose fills and, when properly installed, can help stop air leakage.
But no insulation, by itself, provides an effective air retarder because it cannot completely block airflow. Installing an air retarder along with your insulation and using caulking and weatherstripping seals all gaps and greatly reduces air infiltration into your home (see the section on Air Retarders that follows).
Settling and Loss of Insulating Capacity
Many loose-fill insulations installed in attic cavities will lose some of their
installed R-value over time because of settling. Cellulose loose fill settles
more than rock wool or fiberglass loose fill-about 20% compared to roughly 2%
to 4%. Therefore, install about 20% more blown-in cellulose insulation to
offset this settling. Cellulose manufacturers are required by federal law to
state "settled thickness" on their bags. Because this can be
confusing to consumers, many cellulose producers also specify "installed
thickness" on their bags. Regardless, installed thickness can be estimated
by adding 20% to the stated settled thickness, but be sure not to exceed
previously mentioned weight limits.
Researchers say that it is possible to install loose-fill insulations in wall cavities without settling. If the cavity is completely filled with insulation at the proper density, no significant settling should occur. A general density guideline for walls is roughly 3.5 pounds per cubic foot (17 kilograms per cubic meter) of wall cavity for cellulose and 1.5 pounds per cubic foot (7 kilograms per cubic meter) for fiber-glass or rock wool. These specifications are roughly twice the density of horizontal applications.
One expert suggests this easy-to-follow guideline to ensure that wall cavities are being filled at a density sufficient to prevent settling. Use roughly one 30-pound (13-kilogram) bag of cellulose or about 15 pounds (8 kilograms) of fiberglass or rock wool for every three wall cavities you fill. (Assumptions: 8-foot [2.4-meter] walls, with 16-inch [41-centimeter] on center wall cavities, and 2x4-inch framing studs.)
Fire Resistance
Loose-fill insulations offer very good resistance to fire. Although fiberglass
and rock wool are naturally fire resistant, cellulose's fire resistance is
achieved by adding chemicals. To ensure that it does not present a fire hazard,
cellulose must pass tests established by the Consumer Product Safety
Commission.
Moisture Resistance
The average household generates a considerable amount of water vapor each day
through activities such as cooking, laundry, and bathing. This vapor migrates
into insulated cavities and, if it reaches the dew point (the air temperature
at which water vapor cools enough to condense), it converts to liquid within
the insulation. This reduces the insulation's effective R-value.
All loose-fill insulations are permeable to water vapor. Permeability is the extent to which water vapor can pass through a given material. Fiberglass and rock wool absorb about 1% of their weight, and cellulose absorbs 5% to 20% of its weight. However, any insulation can absorb large amounts of water if exposed to extremely high humidity.
Higher levels of outdoor moisture can also penetrate into insulated cavities. If your roof leaks, for example, moisture can accumulate in the attic cavity and wet the insulation to the point that it mats and compacts. Enough moisture penetration could even cause the ceiling to sag.
If insulation is saturated only one time, it will eventually dry and regain most of its original R-value. However, loose-fill insulations that are repeatedly saturated will lose much of their R-value. Moisture also causes additional problems, such as mold and mildew growth.
See the Vapor Retarders section that follows for steps you can take to ensure that moisture does not create a problem in your insulation.
Upgrading or Repairing Other Building Components
There are other home weatherizing and sealing measures to complete before you
undertake any insulation project. A tight, well-sealed home is more energy
efficient and needs less insulation to keep you and your family comfortable.
Tests have shown that far more cold air infiltration and heat loss result from
improperly sealed windows, doors, ducts, light switches, and outlets than from
insufficient insulation coverage or performance.
Vapor Retarders
If you are adding insulation to an existing ceiling structure and a vapor
retarder is not already installed, consider adding one. Generally, the vapor
retarder should be placed on the warm-in-winter side of the
insulation—usually the side facing the interior living space. However, in
hot, humid climates (primarily the southeastern states), there is controversy
over where a vapor retarder should be placed. No matter where you live, consult
an insulation manufacturer and your building code official for recommendations
on where to place a vapor retarder.
When installing loose-fill insulations, a material such as 6-mil (0.006-inch, or 0.015-centimeter) polyethylene plastic sheeting can be used as a vapor retarder. Paints that act as vapor retarders are also available. These paints may be more practical for retrofitting homes where no vapor retarder exists because they can be installed without removing finished surfaces.
Federal Housing Administration Minimum Property Standards require that any product, including paint, must have a permeability (perm) rating of 1.0 or lower to qualify as a vapor retarder. The lower the perm rating, the greater the material's resistance to vapor penetration. For example, 15-pound (6.8-kilogram) asphalt felt paper has a perm rating of 1.0, while 6-mil polyethylene sheeting is rated at 0.06, and common household aluminum foil is rated at 0.0001.
If the drywall on your ceiling or wall is removed and the insulated area is completely exposed, you can install 6-mil polyethylene sheeting. Be sure that it runs continuously along the surface area of the ceiling and walls, and that no tears occur during installation. Additionally, all penetrations, such as electrical outlets and light switches, should be carefully sealed. There are preformed foam gaskets for use behind outlets and switchplates.
Air Retarders
An air retarder reduces energy loss because it prevents heated or
air-conditioned indoor air from escaping through the building shell. It also
blocks drafts of hot or cold outside air—caused by winds and pressure
differences between the inside and outside of the house—that reduce your
home's comfort and heating or cooling efficiency.
An air retarder is different from a vapor retarder in that it blocks only air, not moisture. The American Society for Testing and Materials specifies that a material must have a perm rating of 5.0 or higher to qualify as an air retarder. Remember, the higher the perm rating of a material, the more moisture can pass through it. An air retarder should have a high perm rating because this allows the escape of moisture that may have migrated into insulated cavities. In new construction, an air retarder (such as "housewrap" products that are now available) is often wrapped around the outside walls before installing the exterior finish, and a vapor retarder is installed around the inside walls before the interior finish is completed.
Installation
Loose-fill insulations are typically installed with special equipment that blows the insulation through a hose and into the cavity. Although loose fills can be installed in both new and retrofit situations, they are especially popular for retrofit projects because they can be installed with minimal disturbances to existing finishes.
Installation often calls for the "two-hole method," which entails drilling two holes spaced vertically between the exterior walls' framing studs. The holes should be 2 inches (5 centimeters) in diameter. Working between each stud, drill one hole 16 inches (41 centimeters) from the top of the wall. Drill the other hole 24 inches (61 centimeters) from the bottom of the wall. The insulation is blown into the holes, then the installation holes are sealed. Installation is most commonly done by professionals who are experienced at operating the equipment to ensure proper density and complete coverage. In conventional and cathedral ceilings, insulation is easier to blow in if an access opening through the ceiling already exists. Otherwise, it may be necessary to drill holes in the ceiling or between the roof rafters.
Cost
At the time this publication was written, the average loose-fill insulation cost per R-value per square foot was about 0.8 cents for cellulose and rock wool and 1.1 cents for fiberglass. These prices were for materials only. The average installed price per R-value per square foot was about 1.2 cents for blown-in cellulose and rock wool and 1.3 cents for fiberglass. Because prices vary in different regions, obtain bids from several insulation contractors or suppliers to determine the specific cost in your area.
Voids and Gaps
To ensure a quality installation, there are several things to watch out for
when installing loose-fill insulation—whether you do the job yourself or
hire a professional.
You may create undesirable voids or gaps if you install the insulation at too low a density or if you do not completely fill the cavity. Voids are most likely to occur at the top of wall cavities, above windows, around doorways, and in the corners of ceiling cavities. Voids also occur if the installation holes are improperly located between the vertical framing studs or if there are too few fill holes. Keep in mind, though, that installers' practices may vary regarding the number, location, and size of installation holes.
It may be difficult to achieve recommended R-values with loose-fill insulation in the eave area of the attic. There are insulation techniques that can be used to insulate this area adequately. Contact the Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Clearinghouse (EREC—see Source List) for advice on this topic.
Fluffing
"Fluffing" occurs when insulation is installed to minimum thickness
but not to minimum weight requirements. The result is a less dense application
of insulation that requires fewer bags. When insulation is "fluffed,"
air passes more easily through it. This means increased heat loss.
Additionally, the fluffed loose-fill insulation will eventually settle and
result in a thinner layer with a lower overall R-value. Fiberglass is more
"fluffable" than cellulose or rock wool.
Intentional fluffing by unscrupulous contractors has been a problem in some parts of the country. To avoid these problems, compare bids from several contractors to see how many bags they specify. Count the number of bags used during installation, either by you or a contractor, and compare it to the instructions on the bag. The manufacturer should specify the amount of insulation required to obtain a particular R-value per square foot (or square meter) of space.
Safety Guidelines
Insulation blown into your ceiling cavities should cover the top plate of the
wall, but be sure the eave vents are not covered. These vents provide necessary
ventilation to your attic, and covering them could result in severe moisture
problems.
Electrical devices and recessed lights (except "IC-rated" fixtures) require 3 inches (8 centimeters) of clearance from insulation.
Pipes for kitchen stoves, wood stoves, and furnaces should only be insulated with fiberglass or rock wool because cellulose may smolder if flue temperatures become hot enough.
Health Considerations
Some observers contend that fiberglass particles can cause cancer if inhaled,
and others state that the fire retardants and insecticides added to cellulose
may be harmful to breathe. While the debate continues as to the health effects
of loose-fill insulations, it is important to protect yourself when installing
any type of insulation. Wear a quality respirator, and wear protective eyewear
and clothing such as goggles, gloves, long-sleeved shirts, and pants to
minimize contact with the insulation.
Insulation fibers can also be drawn into air distribution systems if the ducts are not properly sealed, allowing the fibers to circulate within the living space. Be sure to seal all of your home's ductwork, as well as any other openings where insulation could leak out of the wall or ceiling cavities and into your living space.
Cellulose, fiberglass, and rock wool loose-fill insulations are good choices for many insulation projects. However, they are not suitable for all situations. Conduct careful research and consider factors such as your climate, building design, and budget when selecting the best insulation for your specific circumstances. If you control air leakage and ensure that the insulation you select is installed properly, you can reduce your energy bills and enjoy a more comfortable home.